Plastic alternatives

Compostable Mailers vs Recycled Plastic Mailers

Published 2026-02-06

Compare decision factors: claims, disposal routes, performance, MOQ and customer messaging.

Recycled plastic mailers

Recycled content can reduce virgin plastic demand while staying in a familiar material class for many fulfilment teams.

Customer communication still needs clarity: recycled does not automatically mean widely recyclable in kerbside systems.

Compostable mailers

Compostable mailers can align with brands moving away from conventional plastic entirely — but claims must match certification and local disposal realities.

How brands choose

Choose based on volumes, the claims you want to stand behind, operational constraints and total cost including damages and returns.

Next step

If you want pricing for custom compostable mailers, request a quote. If you are still researching, get the guide first.

FAQ

Our compostable packaging is made from non-GMO, PFAS and BPA free, renewable corn starch and PBAT. It can be made food safe if required. Our other compostable items, such as plates, bowls, cups and cutlery, are made from PHA/sugar cane and are BPA and PFAS free. They are also food safe. Our boxes are made from FSC certified forests and recycled cardboard.

More reading: Articles hub

Get QuoteGet Guide